Before having kids I thought if I ever did whelp a few pups my musical life would, in a sense, be over: I’d be forced to listen to babbling baby fare. Turns out no, not so much. My kids like grownup music just fine, and I don’t have to bring Rafi or Barney or whomever into my home unbidden. Yet there is a dark side to the communal family iPod: my children have seriously put a dent in my appreciation of several previously-enjoyed artists, songs, and albums: Los Campesinos, Jazmine Sullivan’s “Fearless” album, Justin Timberlake, and the Mamma Mia soundtrack, to name a few. They simply have played the death out of this stuff.
Of course, a larger force in pop music killjoy is the Pop Music Industrial Complex itself. Even with an uber-hipster musician husband and our lifestyle free of television and pop-radio, the stuff is out in the ether of modern life. I find myself exposed to songs enough that the constant exposure itself ruins something I perhaps could have enjoyed were it not so relentlessly rammed into my inner ear. Oddly, what constitutes a Permanent Overplay vs. a temporary one is something I can’t quite define. Some popular songs move on peacefully enough into my nostalgic lexicon, and can be heard again without an inner groan (examples: INXS’s “Devil Inside”, Nirvana’s “Smells Like Teen Spirit”, The Wallflower’s “One Headlight”, Def Leppard’s “Pour Some Sugar On Me”, and Shakira’s “La Tortura”). Conversely, “My Most Overplayed Songs Of All Time” are not to be confused with songs and artists played ubermuch that I never particularly enjoyed in the first place, like say Ted Nugent or Lady Gaga. And songs that will never get old, ever, because they are just awesome songs (example: Justin Timberlake’s “SexyBack”, The Rolling Stones’ “Beast of Burden”, and Patti LaBelle’s “Lady Marmalade”).
Yet there are some decent enough songs I just never, ever want to hear again. Like:
Van Morrison’s “Brown-Eyed Girl”
Ah, when this one comes on I break my wrist trying to change the channel or click the “skip” button on my Rhapsody player. What is it about Mr. Morrison’s drink-and-druggy-yet-accessible jazz/blues club style that gets him so much play? Because “Wild Nights” and “Moondance” suffer from serious excellent-yet-overused malaise.
Notable moments: the send-up by Armand Assante and Sheilyn Fenn in spoof-movie Fatal Instinct.
Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Sweet Home Alabama”
Seriously, is anyone not sick of this song? I liked it once at some party in the afternoon after I’d had a beer and while a cute boy was flirting with me. I’ve heard the damn thing so much since that it’s gone in the dastardly files of Southern Rape Rock, and there it resides to rot.
Notable moments: My younger brother looks exactly like a young Artimus Pyle (funny!). Artimus is/was the drummer who survived the plane crash but was later charged with sexual battery against two little girls (oh… not funny!).
Free’s “All Right Now”
The one radio mainstay in the area I’ve spent most my life we have a classic rock radio station – KDUX out of Aberdeen. They play this song about once an hour.
Notable moments: was almost redeemed based on a short scene in the film American Beauty.
Any 90′s Brian Adams
This includes “Everything I Do (I Do For You)” and “Have You Ever Really Loved A Woman” and “Laydeez Love Sensitive Men With Sensitive 90′s Coiffure”. I understand if people find this stuff romantic but if some dude played this song or dedicated it to me he could pretty much guarantee some non-sex, forever. The hell of a thing is, of course, I’m mostly a Brian Adams fan, especially the 80s Adams. So. Whoops.
Live’s “Lightening Crashes”
Wow. Seriously. Shut up. The lyric about a placenta splatting on the floor was particularly annoying. And the video. And the hokey-sounding guitar strum at the beginning. And: everything.
Abba’s “Dancing Queen”
An excellent, joyous song, and I still – depending on my mood – can start to cry upon hearing it (I enjoyed both movies Muriel’s Wedding and Mamma Mia, which heavily feature this track). Heck, “Dancing Queen” was pretty much my wedding song in that it was played and danced to right after vows (we have a home video of my dad shaking his bony ass exuberantly). But: just too much.
Notable moments: Well, if you like Abba, the film Mamma Mia was a lot of fun. Plus, it’s about horny old people. FTW.
Bruce Springsteen’s “Born To Run”
Ye gods I love this song – enough that I want to screech any radio play to a halt. Because I am this close to having heard it too many times at whick.
Listen to instead: “Thunder Road”, “Tenth Avenue Freeze-out”. Actually, there is nothing wrong with a full rotation of the source album “Born To Run” which I have on vinyl [brag] and retains all its charm.
John Cougar Mellencamp’s “Small Town” and “Little Pink Houses”
I have heard these so many times it is impossible to know if my childhood self really enjoyed them or not. < shudder! > And yes, I am aware that the artist’s current moniker is just-plain Mellencamp today, having left the Cougar behind in ’91. I will say, the way, way, way too many times I have heard these tunes are almost made up for by the crunchy-guitar balm of “Hurts So Good”, which although thoroughly redneck-fare is still a great song.
Pink’s “Get The Party Started” and “Don’t Let Me Get Me”
Yeah. Just: no. Pink is awesome tho’.
The Eagles’ “Hotel California”
If I had a time machine, after I did all the cool time-machine stuff and hopefully didn’t screw things up too bad, I’d make it an extra magic time machine by first erasing my memory of the Eagles, then going back to the year before I was born to hear this song for the first time. I imagine it was kind of awesomeness at the time. Dang.
The Gypsy Kings do a fun version of this in The Big Lebowski – just another dose of awesome in a very awesome film.
The B-52s’ “Love Shack”
This is an incredibly fun song! & features a bit of personal esteem from me as it’s the only one I’ve ever karaoke’d! And it was in a group so it kind of doesn’t count! Nevertheless I have heard it too, too, too many times! Damn!
Jet’s “Look What You’ve Done”
You know what, I would have found this song kind of winsomely pretty and sad (yes, I’m aware someone’s depressed Toy Poodle must have written the inane lyrics). Because I really do listen to some pantywaisted stuff occasionally and really enjoy it. But? By the time I first heard the tune it was roundly mocked by those who’d really, really over-heard it. So: thanks again, pop music machine.
LL Cool J.’s “Doin’ It”
You know who’s a talented artist, decent actor, and sexy, sexy man? L.L. Cool J., that’s who. Still, I had enough of him in a handful of months from college thanks to this song which is about, guess what, screwing and how much fun it is (yawn!). For some reason “Mama Said Knock You Out” doesn’t bother me, though it likely received more radio play five years previous. Odd.
Mentioned:
“10 Overplayed Songs on Classic Radio” at glidemagazine.com

